Featured

Santa's Premium Gift Box

Santa's Premium Gift Box

A festive assortment of our holiday favorites. Chocolate covered Graham Crackers, foiled chocolate, Santa's, deluxe assorted chocolates, peanut butter buckeyes, milk nonpareils, sea salt caramels and ..

$69.95

Party Tray

Party Tray

Anthony-Thomas Candy 5.25 lbs. Party Tray filled with two-layers of Pecan Dainties, English Toffee, Sea Salt Caramels, and Peanut Butter Buckeyes...

$125.00

OSU Buckeye Box 7.25 oz.

OSU Buckeye Box 7.25 oz.

Our 12 piece box of Peanut Butter Buckeyes. Packed in our Ohio State Themed Buckeye box.   ..

$8.95

Buckeye Party Tray

Buckeye Party Tray

Anthony-Thomas Buckeye Party Tray made of 35 Buckeyes and 8 oz. of foil wrapped chocolate footballs...

$34.95

Bestsellers

OSU Buckeye Box 3.6oz.

OSU Buckeye Box 3.6oz.

Our 6 piece box of Peanut Butter Buckeyes. Packed in our Ohio State Themed Buckeye box. ..

$4.95

OSU Buckeye Box 14.5 oz.

OSU Buckeye Box 14.5 oz.

Our 24 piece box of Peanut Butter Buckeyes. Packed in our Ohio State Themed Buckeye box.   ..

$16.95

OSU Buckeye Box 7.25 oz.

OSU Buckeye Box 7.25 oz.

Our 12 piece box of Peanut Butter Buckeyes. Packed in our Ohio State Themed Buckeye box.   ..

$8.95

Buckeye Dispenser

Buckeye Dispenser

Perfect for tailgating!! Our Ohio State Buckeyes themed box opens up to reveal 60 individually wrapped peanut butter buckeyes.   ..

$29.95

Classic Buckeye Box 3.6 oz.

Classic Buckeye Box 3.6 oz.

Our 6 piece box of Peanut Butter Buckeyes. Packed in our Classic Buckeye box. ..

$4.95

Two Pound Deluxe Assortment

Two Pound Deluxe Assortment

Our most popular gift box! 2 pounds (approximately 64 pieces) of our finest chocolates. From Soft centers and Nuts to toffee and Caramels, this gift box has a little bit of everything! Avail..

$37.90

14oz. Milk Chocolate English Toffee

14oz. Milk Chocolate English Toffee

We spend two days creating every piece of this candy! Rich almond butter toffee handmade and poured onto slabs, cut into squares and enrobed in our specially blended milk chocolate.   ..

$19.95

Melt-A-Way Mints

Melt-A-Way Mints

Creamy, whipped chocolate centers with a hint of mint under a coating of specially blended milk chocolate. ..

$19.95