Seasonal

Seasonal


Refine Search

Red Buckeye Tin - 3850

Red Buckeye Tin - 3850

Brand New! Buckeye tin bucket packed with buckeyes, caramel corn and peanut butter pretzels! Perfect for tailgating and holiday parties. ..

$44.95

Caffe Europa Mug w/ espresso beans - 3623

Caffe Europa Mug w/ espresso beans - 3623

ONLINE SHIPPING ONLY Beautiful ceramic mug depicting a rustic scene of Italy's beautiful city of Florence. ..

$19.95

Chocolate Dozen Roses Gift Box - 5914

Chocolate Dozen Roses Gift Box - 5914

Romance and Chocolates go hand-in-hand. WOW them with this beautiful gift box filled with 12 chocolate roses. 5.5oz. ..

$12.50

Chocolate L-O-V-E - 5108

Chocolate L-O-V-E - 5108

Our specially blended chocolate molded to spell LOVE. ..

$11.95

16 oz Deluxe Assortment

16 oz Deluxe Assortment

Our most popular gift box! 1 pound (approximately 32 pieces) of our finest chocolates. From Soft centers and Nuts to toffee and Caramels, this gift box has a little bit of everything! Available in Mil..

$24.95

7 oz Milk Chocolate Covered Mini Pretzels - 5178

7 oz Milk Chocolate Covered Mini Pretzels - 5178

7 oz of rich milk chocolate on top of crunchy and salty pretzels. Packaged in a classic white gift box. ..

$12.95

1 oz Chocolate Pumpkin Pop

1 oz Chocolate Pumpkin Pop

A delicious and rich mixture of premium ingredients in a perfect pumpkin shape! This pop is great for busy kids who love to eat on the go--busy adults love them too!..

$2.50

4 oz Milk Chocolate Cat - 5916

4 oz Milk Chocolate Cat - 5916

Our finest chocolate molded into a 4 oz cat. ..

$5.95

8 oz Candy Corn - 5620

8 oz Candy Corn - 5620

A delightful, bright-colored, fall treat. Soft, chewy, and perfect for any occasion. One handful is never enough!..

$3.95

8 oz Jelly Pumpkins - 3721

8 oz Jelly Pumpkins - 3721

A gummy candy for all ages!..

$3.95

8 oz Mellowcreams Mix - 5626

8 oz Mellowcreams Mix - 5626

A mixture of soft Candy Corn and chewy candy pumpkins. A bright colored treat that will leave you reaching for more!..

$3.95

14 oz English Toffee

14 oz English Toffee

On Sale October 1-9th to celebrate our 70 Year Jubilee. We spend two days creating every piece of this candy! Rich almond butter toffee handmade and poured onto slabs, cut into squares and enrobed in ..

$18.17 $25.95

7 oz Large Milk Chocolate Cross - 3708

7 oz Large Milk Chocolate Cross - 3708

A generous sized 7 oz. Milk Chocolate Cross. Perfect for holidays, weddings, first communions, and more!..

$12.50

Sea Salt Caramels - 6 oz.

Sea Salt Caramels - 6 oz.

A fan favorite!! A 6 oz. Box of our bite-sized caramels, enrobed in premium chocolate and topped with sea salt. These are sure to be a hit! Available in both Milk and Dark Chocolate. Mi..

$10.95

1.5 oz - "The Columbus Bar" - 5257

1.5 oz - "The Columbus Bar" - 5257

1.5 oz of premium milk chocolate wrapped in silver foil and a custom Columbus Ohio skyline wrapper. Perfect for businesses, grand openings, and all things Cbus!..

$1.50

8 oz Jelly Beans

8 oz Jelly Beans

8-ounce bag of delicious jelly beans. Available spiced only temporarily. ..

$3.95

Crisps Nuts & Chews

Crisps Nuts & Chews

A one pound (32 piece) assortment of Nuts, Caramels, Nougats, Honeycomb and Toffee coated in our premium blend of chocolate. Available in Milk Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, and Assorted. ..

$25.95

Buckeye Dispenser - Best Value! - 3468

Buckeye Dispenser - Best Value! - 3468

Best Value! Perfect for tailgating!! This beautiful box opens up to reveal 60 individually wrapped creamy peanut butter buckeyes.   ..

$32.95

OSU Buckeye Box 7.25 oz. - 3466

OSU Buckeye Box 7.25 oz. - 3466

Our 12 piece box of Peanut Butter Buckeyes. Packed in our Ohio State Themed Buckeye box.   ..

$9.95

OSU Buckeye Box 3.6oz. - 3465

OSU Buckeye Box 3.6oz. - 3465

Our 6 piece box of Peanut Butter Buckeyes. Packed in our Ohio State Themed Buckeye box. ..

$5.25

OSU Buckeye Box 14.5 oz. - 3467

OSU Buckeye Box 14.5 oz. - 3467

Our 24 piece box of Peanut Butter Buckeyes. Packed in our Ohio State Themed Buckeye box.   ..

$18.95

Chocolate M-O-M

Chocolate M-O-M

Our premium milk chocolate molded to spell MOM ..

$10.95

Ohio Basket - Large - 3567

Ohio Basket - Large - 3567

A beautiful Woodchip Basket filled with some of our favorites. This gorgeous gift comes with Caramel Corn, Chocolate covered mini pretzels, enough individually-wrapped Buckeyes to share, and two large..

$49.95

Chocolate D-A-D

Chocolate D-A-D

Our specially blended chocolate molded to spell DAD. ..

$10.95

Silver OSU Shot Glass - 3609

Silver OSU Shot Glass - 3609

A durable OSU Shot Glass perfect for any football fan. A real game changer. Comes with two individually-wrapped peanut butter Buckeyes. ..

$12.95

OSU Large Platter w/ 24 pc. OSU  Buckeyes - 3539

OSU Large Platter w/ 24 pc. OSU Buckeyes - 3539

An eye-catching, ceramic center piece that will make your gathering one to remember. This decorative platter comes with 24 peanut butter Buckeyes, ready to serve!..

$59.95

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzels - 3927

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzels - 3927

A party favorite! Salted mini pretzels filled with Peanut Butter covered in our premium chocolate.   ..

$9.95

Caramel Corn

Caramel Corn

7 oz of our rich and buttery caramel corn. Also available with nuts!   ..

$5.95

Nutty Caramel Corn

Nutty Caramel Corn

7 oz of our rich and buttery caramel corn with pecans, cashews, and almonds. Also available without nuts! ..

$6.95

Salt Water Taffy Assorted

Salt Water Taffy Assorted

A spring and summer staple!! An 8oz. or 3 LB bag of assorted taffy. Fresh, chewy, and delicious!..

$3.95

Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers

Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers

Six huge graham crackers covered in our specially blended either milk or dark chocolate.            ..

$9.95

12 oz Pecan Bark

12 oz Pecan Bark

Crunchy pecans drenched in milk, dark or white chocolate.   ..

$21.95

12 oz Almond Bark

12 oz Almond Bark

Crunchy almonds drenched in milk, dark or white chocolate.   ..

$21.95

Chocolate Thank You Card - 5855

Chocolate Thank You Card - 5855

Chocolate Thank You Card. Tip: Works well as a gift card holder! 3oz...

$6.95

3 oz Chocolate Cross - 5218

3 oz Chocolate Cross - 5218

3 oz. Cross. Chocolate Cross. Available in Milk, Dark, or White Chocolate.  ..

$4.25

Party Tray - 5250

Party Tray - 5250

Anthony-Thomas Candy 5.25 lbs. Party Tray filled with two-layers of Pecan Dainties, English Toffee, Sea Salt Caramels, and Peanut Butter Buckeyes...

$139.95

Showing 1 to 36 of 37 (2 Pages)